Plug the gaps in agriculture sector

The focus of agricultural reform must be to bridge the gaps between men and women, traditional and modern practices, unpaid labour and entrepreneurship.

The paradox in the agriculture sector is glaring — the share of agricultural GVA (crops and irrigation) in All-India Gross Value Added (GVA) in2022-23 was 10 per cent whereas the share of workers during the same period was 35 per cent. The sector offers much potential for growth and productivity improvements. One of the channels for that is through skilling of workers. However, demand for skilled workers is an indirect demand, that is, it is dependent on the products that are being produced. India’s agriculture is very diverse because of its many climates, soils, and regions. The country is divided into 15 agroclimatic zones, each with different soil types and weather conditions that support different crops. Designing a top-down strategy to assess skill shortage and gaps would be erroneous.

That idea drove the work in the MSDE-NCAER’s National Skill Gap Study for High Growth Sectors (2025). The objective in that report was to develop a unified dynamic framework for assessing skills shortages and gaps in the country. This framework could either be applied to sectors or States/districts. The framework was developed using seven high growth sectors. One of them was the ‘growing of cereals, leguminous crops and oilseeds.

The key sectoral results from the report are given here:

The agricultural value chain — where skills meet technology: A modern agricultural economy is not built in the field alone; it spans a value chain stretching from crop planning to final market delivery. Agri-tech and agro-tech both define the sector. At each stage, digital technologies that are reshaping the possibilities are discussed here (Department of Agriculture, Cooperation and Farmer Welfare 2021):

(a) Crop planning now leverages AI, machine learning, and big data, with soil testing labs and agri-tech start-ups offering precision recommendations. Farmers, however, need training to interpret and adopt these insights.

(b) Cultivation increasingly involves smart tractors, drones, and IoT sensors that monitor soil and crop health. Yet, without skilled machine operators, extension agents, and credit facilitators, adoption remains limited.

(c) Harvesting has shifted from manual reaping to mechanised harvesters, but women farmers are rarely trained to use these machines, excluding them from efficiency gains.

(d) Supply chain and markets are embracing blockchain for traceability, big data for price forecasting, and AI for logistics. Still, at the mandi level, workers handling grading, packing, and quality testing lack systematic training.

Workforce characteristics (PLFS 2022-23): Overall, 35 per cent of work-ers in the sector were not literate. Almost all the workers had not received any technical education. 32.2 per cent of workers had received non-formal vocational education, mostly through hereditary means. This inheritance-based skill transfer, while valuable for traditional practices, leaves farmers ill-prepared for modern farming systems that de-mand literacy in digital tools, market intelligence, and climate-smart agriculture. This mismatch is stark: while technology gallops ahead, skills lag behind, creating bottlenecks in productivity and inclusion.

Occupations: Among the number of jobs, 70 per cent of the jobs were in the occupational role of market gardeners and crop growers. Twenty percent of the workers are agricultural, forestry and fishery labourers. Nine per cent of the workers were subsistence crop farmers.

Engagement: Majority of the workers were self-employed. As much as39.5 per cent of workers were own-account workers; 3.2 per cent, employ-ers; 19 per cent, casual wage labour; and 38.2 per cent, unpaid family workers.

Women farmers — the invisible backbone: 41.4 per cent of workers en-gaged in this sector were females. Fifty per cent of female workers were illiterate compared to 25 per cent of male workers. Majority of the fe-male workers were low-skilled compared to males who were low-medium skilled. Moreover, women were concentrated in the most pre-carious job roles: casual wage labour and subsistence farming.

In the category of agricultural, forestry, and fishery labourers, women make up 52 per cent — a telling indicator of gendered vulnerability. In contrast, in the relatively more secure occupation of market gardeners and crop growers, women account for only 33.7 per cent. The data high-lights a structural inequity. Over 63 per cent of women in this sub-sector were engaged as unpaid family workers, compared to just 20.8 per cent of men. Only 0.5 per cent of women were entrepreneurs, and a mere 11.8per cent were own-account workers.

The majority remained invisible contributors, neither recognised nor remunerated adequately. This gender imbalance is not inevitable; it is the outcome of systemic neglect of women in agricultural skilling pro-grammes. Studies such as Sarkar (2020) and Aryal et al (2021) show that the probability of farm machinery ownership — and by extension, agency in decision-making — rises sharply with education and training. Skilling women, therefore, is not just a matter of equity but of economic efficiency.

Geographical clusters: Based on four parameters — institutional, business infrastructure, human resources and government support (Sutawi et al 2022), the top three geographical clusters in this sub-sector were Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra and Rajasthan. The PLFS (2022-23) showed that 75 per cent of workers in this sub-sector were concentrated in just nine States — Uttar Pradesh, Madhya Pradesh, Bihar, Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh, West Bengal, Rajasthan, Odisha, and Andhra Pradesh.

Stakeholders survey: The challenge in this part was given the agricultural diversity of India, who should we talk to and whether these discussions would be relevant from one part of the country to another. A bot-tom-up strategy was adopted, where within one agro-climatic zone, all stakeholders along the value chain were identified. Discussions were carried out with those stakeholders. These informed us that there were both supply-side and demand-side challenges. Three key findings from stakeholders’ survey about job roles were:

(a) Farmers and extension service providers need continuous re-skilling and upskilling along with basic, digital and financial literacy, upgrading of knowledge in agriculture and entrepreneurship skills.

(b) District-specific identification of new and emerging job roles fo-cussing in the ‘sunrise’ aspects of the sector and developing requisite training programmes for it. For example, groundwater detection technologists in water-starved districts of Haryana.

(c) Identification of job roles which are difficult to fill. Top three job roles that were facing demand shortage were drone operator, agriculture advisor/crop advisor in agri-tech, IT-GIS specialist (agri-tech) and farm machinery service technician.

India’s agriculture stands at a crossroads. On one side lies the prospect of stagnation — where millions remain locked into low productivity, hereditary occupations, and gendered inequities. On the other lies a future of inclusive modernisation, where technology and skills together drive prosperity. Bridging the divide — between men and women, be-tween traditional and modern practices, between unpaid labour and entrepreneurship— must be the central focus of agricultural reform. Only then can the sector not only feed the nation but also empower those who make it possible.

Joshi and Sahu are Fellows and Bhandari is a Professor at NCAER. Views are personal.

How India really spends its working hours

The most immediate and striking observation is the prevalence of the tertiary sector, which consumes the largest share of time for the overall population’s paid work, but it is overwhelmingly dominated by urban population.

India’s vast and diverse economy is driven by the time and toil of millions. But beyond headline figures like GDP and employment rates lies a deeper, more complex story, one told by how people actually spend their working hours. Recent data from the Time Use Survey provides critical insight and uncovers stark inequalities across gender, age, location, and types of employment.

Agriculture andallied work: A heavier load on women and rural India

Nearly half (46.4%) of all self-employed work time is spent in the primary sector (agriculture, etc.). This figure is significantly higher for women (61.4%) compared to men (42.8%), and women also contribute heavily to primary sector work among casual labourers.

The disparity is geographic as well, self-employed individuals in rural India dedicate 61.4% of their time to the primary sector, which plummets to just 6.7% in urban areas, highlighting a stark rural-urban divide in the nature of work.

Secondary sector: Casual labourers keep the wheels turning

In contrast, the secondary sector, which includes manufacturing, construction, and mining, employs 12.3% of self-employed workers’ time and 12.8% of regular salaried employees.

However, it is casual labourers who dominate here, with over 47% of their work time spent in this sector. Male casual labourers, in particular, devote 54.5% of their time to secondary work, indicating their vital, yet vulnerable, role in India’s industrial and construction backbone.

The sector’s reliance on casual labour also underscores systemic issues like the lack of job security, absence of benefits, and minimal labour protections. Urban self-employed individuals are more likely to participate in this sector than their rural counterparts, reflecting a persistent urban-rural imbalance in industrial employment opportunities.

Tertiary sector: A modern economy still out of reach for many

At 83.5%, the services sector, which includes activities like trade, transport, and professional services, is where most of India’s regular salaried workforce spends its work time.

The time spent rises to 88.3% for salaried women, compared to 82.3% for men. However, access to the service sector remains largely urban. Among self-employed urban workers, 73.3% of their time is spent in services related work, while only 28.1% of rural self-employed workers’ time is spent in similar activities.

These numbers suggest that the modern service-driven economy is mostly urban centric, further entrenching regional inequalities.

Rural vs urban workdays: A tale of dichotomy

India’s rural and urban labour landscapes are strikingly different. Among the self-employed, rural individuals devote a majority of their work time (61.4%) to the primary sector, indicating a strong focus on agriculture and related activities.

In contrast, urban self-employed workers primarily operate in the tertiary sector, spending 73.3% of their time on services, trade, and informal businesses. The secondary sector plays a moderate role (18.9%) in urban areas but remains marginal in rural settings (9.8%).

For regular salaried workers, the majority of work time in both rural and urban areas is concentrated in the tertiary sector – 79.3% (rural) and 86.3% (urban areas) – highlighting a predominant reliance on service-based employment.

The primary sector accounts for only a small portion of salaried work time in both rural and urban areas, while the secondary sector makes up 14.2% of work time in rural and 11.8% in urban areas.

Casual labourers in rural areas divide most of their time between the primary sector (40.8%) and the secondary sector (44.6%), reflecting dependence on both sectors. In urban areas, casual workers spend a larger share of their time (57.1%) in the secondary sector, while 32.3% of their time is spent in tertiary sector jobs.

Thus, the distribution of work time reveals a clear occupational divide between rural and urban areas, underscoring the differing economic structures and employment opportunities that shape the nature of work.

Age and labour: Shifting burdens through the life cycle

Work patterns also vary markedly by age. The core working-age population (23–50 years) spends 84.2% of its regular salaried time in the services sector, a trend echoed among youth aged 15–22 (78.3%).

In contrast, older workers (51 years and above) have shifted back to the primary sector, especially in self-employment, spending 57.9% of their time there, peaking at 63.3% for those aged 65 and above. This return to primary work in later life reflects the limited coverage of pensions and continued reliance on informal or subsistence labour.

Rethinking employment through a time lens

Time-use data on paid employment in India reveals that the national workforce is operating under vastly different economic conditions across various sectors. It paints a picture of a fragmented labour market where demographic divisions run deep.

The most immediate and striking observation is the prevalence of the tertiary sector, which consumes the largest share of time for the overall population’s paid work, but it is overwhelmingly dominated by urban population.

Furthermore, the overall greater reliance on self-employed and casual labour of women and older age groups on primary sector activities points to a broader structural issue of informalisation and a lack of job security, demanding urgent policy attention for inclusive and equitable economic development.

Palash is Fellow at the National Council of Applied Economic Research, New Delhi; Wankhar is a retired government officer, Views are personal.

NCAER News: October 2025

NCAER News is a monthly digest where you can learn about NCAER’s research outputs, its latest events, and offerings.

India Human Development Survey: October 2025

The IHDS Forum is a monthly update of socio-economic developments in India by the IHDS research community, based on the India Human Development Survey, jointly conducted by NCAER and the University of Maryland. While two earlier rounds of the survey were completed in 2004-05 and 2011-12, respectively. Fieldwork for the third round was undertaken in 2022-24 and the data is currently being cleaned and processed.

Click here for previous issues

The NCAER Business Expectations Survey for India Second Quarter 2025–26

The National Council of Applied Economic Research (NCAER), one of India’s premier economic policy research think tanks, carried out the 134th Round of its Business Expectations Survey (BES) in September 2025. NCAER has been carrying out the BES every quarter since 1992, covering 484 firms across four regions.

    Get updates from NCAER